America’s Quiet Divorce
After years of searching for the right person, you finally find the one who presumably wants to spend the rest of their life with you, the person who loves you so much, you no longer have to pretend. But what if it isn’t true.
Marriage is terrifying at its core—the union between two people who can stand before each other fully unmasked.
What if after years of togetherness, through every season of human stress, there is simply no mystery left. He’s seen her without makeup. She’s seen him in stained sweatpants—Both fat, thin, out of shape. Both stressed over problems at work, disengaged, arguing over dirty dishes at the kitchen sink, the unhappiness etched in permanent frowns and tired eyes. When the masks are removed, we are completely vulnerable in front of each other, and we don’t always like what we see.
What happens when we stand before our partner truly known—and they leave us for something or someone better?
Will they still love me when they really know me?
Or am I only lovable in pieces?
Divorce is our worst fear incarnate. After really knowing me, he says, I chose wrong. I don’t want you anymore.
When a spouse leaves, it captures something essential about being human: our deep-seated fear of being rejected at the moment we are most vulnerable.
I have lived it and survived it.
The church provides a spiritual form of marriage. Before the altar, in the colored light of stained-glass windows, believers remove the veil. They are finally seen in a room of witnesses. But if we are rejected, uncared for, or neglected after stripping ourselves so bare, it might lead to the worst pain imaginable—a spiritual divorce.
You went to a place you hoped would be safe and the opposite happened. You were hurt, abused, or mistreated. It is the reason why nearly half of American Christians are now unchurched.
The quiet divorce of Christians from the church is a sad story—one that is gaining momentum. Paul tells us in Ephesians that husbands are to love their wives as Christ loved the church, a sacrificial love, agape, that centers on what is best for the other. It is not dependent on performance or worthiness. Most of us are desperately seeking this kind of love, yet in many churches, seekers encounter something very different: a performative culture, and leaders who use their sheep for their own gain rather than loving and shepherding the flock.
Performance culture is the quiet economy of quid pro quo. It rewards those who already have something to offer—the rich, the talented, the healthy, the beautiful. If you are seen as having little to offer, you become invisible. When this mentality shows up in holy places, it doesn’t just disappoint. It wounds. The seeker goes looking for God and instead finds something transactional in its place, a marketplace in the place of the altar.
A rejection from a church is like God himself, casting us out of his presence.
Church hurt, like divorce leaves us hollow. We lose our soft edges and build armor. If we ever enter a church again, we have learned to be alert—guarded. If I am being honest, I no longer enter any human space with my heart on my sleeve. You can call me cynical, but I am older and no longer naive. I do not expect to experience agape love as a daily norm, even among fellow Christians.
If I encounter sacrificial love, even in moments, I consider myself blessed. I am also not naive about myself. We have all sinned and fall short of God’s glory as Paul tells us in Romans. In other words, how can churches ever be a safe place if we’re all so, so… human?
Perhaps it isn’t Bibles we should be bringing to church, but boxing gloves. This exposes the real question: Do we have the right to be vulnerable in a church?
When we trust people with our secrets, we must hope they are spiritually mature enough to carry that weight. Many are not. True spiritual sharing grows out of trust over time. Christians must practice discernment; we can be loving while still recognizing that entrusting certain people with our vulnerability would be unwise.
I am sending you out like sheep among wolves. Therefore be as shrewd as snakes and as innocent as doves. Matthew 10:16
Jesus calls us to use discernment, even amongst other Christians. Church hurt is real. According to a recent LifeWay poll, one out of three Christians has left a church due to disenchantment with leadership. In Ezekiel, the prophet condemns the false shepherds:
Ah, shepherds of Israel who have been feeding yourselves! Should not shepherds feed the sheep?
The word “shepherd” comes from the Hebrew word ra’ah—care, provision, protection, and presence. It is the same ra’ah the Psalmist promises when he says, The Lord is my shepherd. The sheep do not earn this care. Ra’ah is the natural calling of the shepherd and it flows from him like water from a stream.
That is the standard.
The shepherd calling is the same calling of a marriage partner. It is the calling of the church. The spouse is called not just to be present, but to care deeply, to shape their life around the care of their partner.
Yet we live in a world where the spouse betrays and the shepherd neglects. The standard often feels just out of reach.
Subscribe below to finish this article and join a community of readers learning to find God in the ruins.
Welcome to No Pretty Bow
A place for people who have discovered that faith is often messier, harder, and more beautiful than they expected.
Debby Handman is a former minister (M.Div), educator, and single mother writing from the misty crossroads of faith and survival in rural Oregon. She is the author of the acclaimed novels House on Sand and The Gambler’s Wife, and her upcoming release, House of Broken Vessels.
